In the streaming era, it’s easy to fixate on one number: streams. But streams alone don’t show the real impact of your music.
True success is what happens when people actually care about your songs - when they save it, share it, show up, or use it in their own content. If you only chase numbers the algorithm rewards, you miss the wins happening right in front of you.
Why Streams Don’t Tell the Whole Story
Streams show how far your music has travelled. But they don’t show who it’s reaching, why it’s connecting, or what it’s inspiring.
Two artists can have the same number of plays but vastly different careers: one built on passive playlist listens, the other on loyal fans who buy tickets, merch, and show up for every post. Guess which one lasts longer?
True success isn’t about playing the algorithm’s game - it’s about building an audience that sticks around.
What to Measure Instead
1. Fan Engagement
Look at how fans interact with you - comments, DMs, replies, reposts, and UGC (user-generated content).
- Are people responding to your stories?
- Are they saving your songs or sharing them with friends?
- Are they turning up at your shows?
Engagement reveals emotional connection and that’s what drives longevity.
2. Growth Across Platforms
Track how your following and engagement evolve over time. Are you converting listeners into followers across Spotify, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube?
- Quality > quantity - slow, steady growth from real people beats viral spikes that disappear.
- Look for consistency in where your audience comes from and how they behave.
3. Merch and Direct Support
Sales on Bandcamp, merch at shows, or tips via platforms like Ko-fi or Patreon show fans are willing to invest in you. That’s real, measurable support that goes beyond algorithms.
4. Brand Development
How well do people understand who you are as an artist?
- Is your visual identity consistent?
- Do you have a recognisable tone or world fans can step into?
- Are other creatives or brands reaching out to collaborate?
Your brand’s strength reflects how clearly people connect your art to a story.
5. Community Building
The strongest artists don’t just have listeners - they have communities.
- Are fans talking to each other in your comments or Discord?
- Do they share your values or aesthetics?
- Are you creating spaces where they can gather (online or IRL)?
Community is what turns moments into movements.
Redefine What “Success” Means to You
Take a step back and ask yourself:
“What does a win look like for me right now?
It might be:
- Selling out your first small venue
- Building 1,000 loyal email subscribers
- Getting your first piece of press coverage
- Or simply finishing and releasing your best work yet
When you track these milestones alongside your streaming data, you build a much more realistic and fulfilling picture of growth.
The Takeaway
Streams matter, but they’re just one signal in a much bigger ecosystem. Real success happens where connection, creativity, and consistency meet.
Measure what truly matters to you: the people who care, the moments that move them, and the story you’re telling through your art.
Because in the long run, a thousand real fans will take you further than a million empty plays.
Ready to pitch your music to Spotify and Apple Music editors?
Head back to the un:hurd app to explore more tools and resources for playlist promotion.
Not an un:hurd user yet?
Join thousands of independent artists who are using un:hurd to streamline their music marketing and maximise their impact. Sign up today!
